What Is an Appeal in a Personal Injury Case?
An appeal asks a higher court to decide whether the trial court got the law right. The party who appeals is the appellant; the other side is the appellee.
Most personal injury cases settle and never reach a verdict. When a case does go to trial, the losing side, or a side unhappy with the amount awarded, may appeal. That can extend the case by months or longer.
Who Can Appeal and Why
Either party can appeal. A defendant may appeal a large verdict. An injured plaintiff may appeal a loss or an award that seems legally flawed.
Common reasons for a personal injury appeal include:
- The judge admitted or excluded important evidence improperly
- The jury received incorrect instructions on the law
- The evidence was legally insufficient to support the verdict
- Misconduct by a juror, lawyer, or party affected the outcome
- The damages awarded do not match the law or the evidence
The error usually must have been raised during trial and must have probably caused an improper judgment. Harmless mistakes do not lead to reversal.
How the Texas Appeal Process Works
Texas civil appeals usually go first to one of the state’s intermediate courts of appeals. The steps generally look like this:
- Notice of appeal. Filed with the trial court, generally within 30 days after judgment is signed. Some post-trial motions extend that time.
- The record. The clerk’s record and court reporter’s transcript are sent to the appeals court.
- Briefs. Each side files written arguments. The court may also hear oral argument.
- Decision. The court affirms, reverses, modifies, or sends the case back to the trial court.
A party who loses in the court of appeals may ask the Supreme Court of Texas to review the case. That court chooses which cases it hears.
How an Appeal Affects Your Claim
An appeal delays final payment, and the result can change. A verdict may be upheld, reduced, increased, or sent back for a new trial. Many cases settle while an appeal is pending because both sides want certainty.
If a judgment was just entered in your case, act quickly. Appeal deadlines are short, and missing one can end the right to appeal. A free case review can help you understand your options.
About Brad Parker
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I appeal a personal injury verdict in Texas?
Yes, if you believe the trial court made a legal error that affected the result. Common grounds include wrongly admitted or excluded evidence, incorrect jury instructions, or a verdict with no legally sufficient evidence behind it. Simply disliking the jury's decision is not enough. The appeals court looks for mistakes in how the law was applied.
How long do I have to appeal a civil judgment in Texas?
In most civil cases, the notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days after the judgment is signed. Certain post-trial motions, such as a motion for new trial, can extend that deadline, and accelerated appeals have shorter deadlines. Because the timing is strict, talk with a lawyer as soon as the judgment is signed.
Does an appeal mean a new trial?
No. The court of appeals reviews the written record, including transcripts, exhibits, and the lawyers' briefs. It does not hear new witnesses. If it finds a harmful error, it may reverse the judgment, change it, or send the case back to the trial court, which can lead to a new trial.
Can a case still settle during an appeal?
Yes. Parties often keep negotiating while an appeal is pending. The risk and delay of an appeal can push both sides toward a settlement, and an agreement can end the appeal at any point before the appellate court rules.
More resources